Bo Eder
Platinum Member
First world problem: do I get a swish or not?
Most of you know I've bought an entirely new set of Paiste cymbals after 50 years of playing nothing but Zildjians, and while I have the basics covered (hats, crash, ride), I feel like I should add another crash to balance out the set, but then feel like the crash and ride I have can serve the purpose of two crashes when I need to do that (my ride is a thin, so it crashes and washes probably more than anyone here wants it to). When I played my Zildjians, I have the 22" Swish Knocker which is a sweet cymbal for riding and crashing. But part of me feels like the swish sound is so cliche'd because of how the jazz players use them (or how Neil Peart used his), and I don't think I'm doing it any great justice when I use it. People hear this exotic riding going on in the background, but who knows if it's too much for the audience?
But I've discovered that Paiste makes the 2002 24" swish cymbal (that JR Robinson really likes), and it does sound quite glorious. I'm just afraid to spend the $470 for a cymbal I know won't get played all the time. But I'm not kidding when I say it's glorious! If you recall Billy Cobham on his debut album, "Spectrum" he used that swish to great effect for years (I think his was a 26"!). Part of me says it will be a cool investment, but the practical side of me doesn't know where it would actually get used in my current cover-band situations.
So this is really just a question of want vs. need. Would you invest the $470 for the swish goodness that you may not use all the time? Or would you just get another regular crash to balance the kit out visually?
Most of you know I've bought an entirely new set of Paiste cymbals after 50 years of playing nothing but Zildjians, and while I have the basics covered (hats, crash, ride), I feel like I should add another crash to balance out the set, but then feel like the crash and ride I have can serve the purpose of two crashes when I need to do that (my ride is a thin, so it crashes and washes probably more than anyone here wants it to). When I played my Zildjians, I have the 22" Swish Knocker which is a sweet cymbal for riding and crashing. But part of me feels like the swish sound is so cliche'd because of how the jazz players use them (or how Neil Peart used his), and I don't think I'm doing it any great justice when I use it. People hear this exotic riding going on in the background, but who knows if it's too much for the audience?
But I've discovered that Paiste makes the 2002 24" swish cymbal (that JR Robinson really likes), and it does sound quite glorious. I'm just afraid to spend the $470 for a cymbal I know won't get played all the time. But I'm not kidding when I say it's glorious! If you recall Billy Cobham on his debut album, "Spectrum" he used that swish to great effect for years (I think his was a 26"!). Part of me says it will be a cool investment, but the practical side of me doesn't know where it would actually get used in my current cover-band situations.
So this is really just a question of want vs. need. Would you invest the $470 for the swish goodness that you may not use all the time? Or would you just get another regular crash to balance the kit out visually?