jda
Diamond Member
Tommy James yes..
but nary a Shondell survived
en.wikipedia.org
but nary a Shondell survived
Bands where NOBODY is an original member!
- Thread starter bermuda
- Start date
rungeflash
Well-known Member
Judas Priest
(and I thought Ian Hill was an original member….but wiki says negative to that)
(and I thought Ian Hill was an original member….but wiki says negative to that)
Son of Vistalite Black
Well-known Member
Son of Vistalite Black saw the non-original Thin Lizzy in 2014 -- and we're really arguing a technicality since Scott Gorham and Brian Downey were in the "Boys Are Back in Town" incarnation that we all remember. The 2014 version rocked hard, and won a new fan, Son of Son of Vistalite Black.
SoVB also saw Sepultura a few years ago ... while possibly insincere, they are a powerfully intense entity to see from a few feet away.
All in all, SoVB is more inclined to see a bunch of replacements in a club than pay $16 for a beer whilst watching whichever aging rocker is playing our horrible-sounding basketball dome.
DrumEatDrum
Platinum Member
I don't think Heart really counts though. Technically, the band existed at the club level before Ann and Nancy joined, but the band that got signed to a record deal had the sisters in it. If the sisters hadn't joined, likely the band would never have gotten signed and no one ever hears of them.
I don't believe in counting members who were in the band before the band's 1st album came out.
charliedrummer
Senior Member
I envision KISS becoming something of a franchise whereby there will eventually be several touring groups with members dressed like the original four. It'll be something similar to Menudo where the members are easily interchangeable.
DrumEatDrum
Platinum Member
I agree.
A few years ago I went to see another forum member open for Asia. But not that Asia, the 2nd version of Asia who have has NO members from the original lineup. Yet they still played the hit songs from the 80s. It seemed, well, rather, odd.
Not having key members of the albums that made the band popular is hard to get into. I love Queensryche, and heck, I even think their latest album is pretty good. But I can't find the motivation to pay to see them, knowing it's just 2 out of the original 5 members now.
Though I suppose it does depend on the band. I absolutely love Katatonia, and they have had numerous line-up changes. But the two members who write all the material are still in the band, so it's easier to still support them. Similar with Lacuna Coil. Despite all the band member changes, the 3 main songwriters are still in the band, and so it's easy to feel good about paying to go to a show.
BobC
Silver Member
Iron Butterfly. No original members left in the band. The only one still alive is Doug Ingle.
Several years ago, the Sellersville Theatre in Bucks County, PA brought the fake Iron Butterfly in for a couple of shows, and were pressured by their agent to offer a paid meet & greet after the show. I was aghast. People had to pay to get their old albums signed by a bunch of anonymous musicians who were leasing the name. What a fraud. I was so incensed, I spoke to the theater's owner and explained to her that it was a ripoff. The Sellersville Theatre is a very nice small venue, very clean and well maintained, with a great staff, and they present shows that are reasonably priced, so this little escapade seemed totally opposite of the way they usually do things. She said she understood, but the meet & greet happened anyway.
Likewise, years ago, some band of nobodies were out on the circuit calling themselves The Byrds. They apparently leased the name from drummer Michael Clark, who at one time, had legal rights to the band's name, simply because McGuinn, Crosby and Hillman weren't using it. Clark had a history of using The Byrds' name for his own gain, hiring mostly unknown musicians. By that time, David Crosby owned the name, so I called his manager, Elliot Roberts, and informed him of what was going on. Within two or three weeks, the fake Byrds were history.
Blackfoot's Ricky Medlocke leased the band's name out to four no-names several years ago as well. At least he put out a press release and website telling fans about it. I don't know if they are still around or not. I saw Skynyrd on TV for a minute on NYE lip synching "Sweet Home Alabama" with Medlocke on guitar. Technically, he was an original member of the band, but left before they recorded their first album. If you don't consider him original, then Skynyrd has no original members either. They're all dead, with the exception of Artimus Pyle, and maybe one or two backup singers.
The whole "fake band" thing just reeks of greed and dishonesty.
Several years ago, the Sellersville Theatre in Bucks County, PA brought the fake Iron Butterfly in for a couple of shows, and were pressured by their agent to offer a paid meet & greet after the show. I was aghast. People had to pay to get their old albums signed by a bunch of anonymous musicians who were leasing the name. What a fraud. I was so incensed, I spoke to the theater's owner and explained to her that it was a ripoff. The Sellersville Theatre is a very nice small venue, very clean and well maintained, with a great staff, and they present shows that are reasonably priced, so this little escapade seemed totally opposite of the way they usually do things. She said she understood, but the meet & greet happened anyway.
Likewise, years ago, some band of nobodies were out on the circuit calling themselves The Byrds. They apparently leased the name from drummer Michael Clark, who at one time, had legal rights to the band's name, simply because McGuinn, Crosby and Hillman weren't using it. Clark had a history of using The Byrds' name for his own gain, hiring mostly unknown musicians. By that time, David Crosby owned the name, so I called his manager, Elliot Roberts, and informed him of what was going on. Within two or three weeks, the fake Byrds were history.
Blackfoot's Ricky Medlocke leased the band's name out to four no-names several years ago as well. At least he put out a press release and website telling fans about it. I don't know if they are still around or not. I saw Skynyrd on TV for a minute on NYE lip synching "Sweet Home Alabama" with Medlocke on guitar. Technically, he was an original member of the band, but left before they recorded their first album. If you don't consider him original, then Skynyrd has no original members either. They're all dead, with the exception of Artimus Pyle, and maybe one or two backup singers.
The whole "fake band" thing just reeks of greed and dishonesty.
Last edited:
2 hit wonder
Junior Member
Small time bands, like ones I play in, still make social media posts about opening for bands like Molly Hatchett.
Our former guitar player was in the Lawrence Welk Orchestra well after Lawrence died.
Bands like the Temptations or Spinners toured in the 80s with all new lineups.
Our former guitar player was in the Lawrence Welk Orchestra well after Lawrence died.
Bands like the Temptations or Spinners toured in the 80s with all new lineups.
brady
Platinum Member
Thanks for clearing that up. I figured YOU would know!
I thought I remembered Peter commenting that the person in question had not even been in the band that long. Could have just been frustration coming out in an interview...
brady
Platinum Member
Artimus wasn't the original drummer though. However, he was there for most of their prime. Bob Burns was the original drummer.
AudioWonderland
Silver Member
Avatars.... who's original in Foreigner?
I think in their case it's a matter of aging-out, but certainly none of the originals are there anymore.
Hollywood Jim
Platinum Member
The Zeppelins don't have any original members in the band.
These are the original members of the Zeppelins formed in 1966. Only me and the bass player remain with us today.
.
These are the original members of the Zeppelins formed in 1966. Only me and the bass player remain with us today.
.
BobC
Silver Member
I know. Bob Burns was gone before their real popularity occurred.
BobC
Silver Member
Maybe the only guy left is Rich, the sax player.