Haven't chimed in so far. This is pretty interesting.
Until Vinnie say's something, it's all speculation, but, if it wasn't the sound he wasn't digging, there may have been an offer he couldn't pass up.
To me, DW comes to mind as a contender in that they have "everything" someone could need as an artist, in the studio and for touring, plus the marketing visibility.
They can pretty much make up anything, and have a few kits here and there. They make their own shells, AND John Good appears to be so into it--the creating stuff for the artists, and it seems like it's not that big a deal.
The DW Maple/Mahogany shells are awesome, and so are the Jazz shells. Those 2 lines have a lot of sound character covered.
Look at some of the crazy stuff they have done for Neil Peart. Beisides the Steampunk kit, there was the NHL kit that was used for what? A commercial seen by not that many people to get anything of substance from it from a business stand point.
From a FYeah! angle, it's pretty cool. There's also Terry Bozzio, who had some hand in designing things as well as having crazy, cool, interesting kits. Other artists too.
AND with DW there's no "parent company" in the way holding anything back, IF that was a problem in some way--wild unfounded speculation on my part. Maybe.
I just have a feeling it could be some HIGHER UP higher up's that might have soured things in some way.
A couple years ago, Frankie Banali, who was HUGE lover/supporter of Ludwig drums, and a great Ambassador for them had someone say they "wanted to see his resume", and were going to decide weather to "keep him on" as an endorser. He posted things on his site.
This was BEFORE anyone really started buying the drums again! He told them to shove off.
What a way to treat someone who was in a good position to promote the product, and did so for many years. he's not highly visible as much anymore, but to do that? Really? I wonder if that person is even still with Ludwig.