First off, I just wanted to say that I stumbled on this thread (I really cannot remmeber how) and it prompted me to sign up to the MB
I've been drumming about 28 years, and while I think in some regards I'm decent, other times I realize I suck compared to all the great drummers named here (and many more that probably haven't been mentioned).
I have to say that Moving Pictures was a watershed album for me, and every other drummer in my general age range. It's the album that made my brain explode for the first time. So, top to bottom, it's hard to beat based on the criteria put out in this question. But I did want to throw out some names for conversations sake.
"Condemed", Steve Shelton (Confessor) - Very unique approach to contructing parts for songs. The song condemed still blows me away every time I hear it. Listen to a stream here:
http://www.confessorband.com/condemned.html
"Blizzard of Oz", Lee Kerslake (Ozzy) - One of the underrated rock drummers of our time. Played with power and feel.
"She", Raymond Weber (Harry Connick, Jr) - Tasty grooves throughout the entire album. I love his understated style.
"In Abstensia", Gavin Harrison (Porcupine Tree) - Fits in lots of interesting notes, but not to the point where he is overplaying. Standout track to me is "The Sound of Muzak". To me is sums up everything I love about Gavin's approach to drums.
"Stoner Witch", Dale C (Melvins) - A great, very unique drummer. Plays heavy, plays slow, creates very unique parts . Stand-out track s are "Revolve", "Roadbull", and "At The Stake"
Wow, I could go on. Ive been listening to many of the recomendations here. Just got turned on to the band Morphine and love it! That's the best part about these typoe discussions. Now, I hang my head in shame of not being familiar with Elvin Jones. It appears I must get educated right quick!