Re: Did some experimenting with my bass drums and a Super Kick 1 and 2 (video)
What sound are you trying to achieve with the style of music you play? What combination, so far, are you liking more? I'm hearing a lot of your room on the video and I watched it three time now trying to get a feeling for it. I'm also hearing either your pedal or it might just be the attack of the beater, I can't be sure. Originally I thought I was hearing some loose snares in the background. If it is the attack of the beater, the sound is probably just bouncing from the rear wall of the room. I earlier mentioned the port hole because that usually influences the lower fundamental frequencies and resonance of the drum almost as much as the heads themselves, in addition to the tuning and pitch of the heads. I do own resonant heads with 4 and 5" portholes, but they really never get used.
With demoing different heads, it's really easy for an outsider to give his or her personal favorites, because it turns out to be just that, having absolutely no idea what sound you are striving for. Personally I never put anything inside my bass drums. I usually use either Evans EQ4 or Remo Power Stroke Three batter heads. They have a small internal band of Mylar which dampens the sound to a very mall degree, i really wouldn't call it muffling. If for some reason I have a resonant head that doesn't respond well or sounds a bit too plasticy, such as Ludwigs logo heads, I'll just use a small width of felt behind the resonant head. The width of this felt is determined by the diameter of the drum. I'm usually after a deep, more open and resonant sound from the bass drum, a sort of middle ground that sounds great both live, with or without reinforcement, and also in a studio environment with very little additional adjustments being necessary. So whatever modifications you make to your drum's resonant heads, it will have a definite impact on the overall sound of the drum.
Dennis