No kidding, that's great… hope it comes through. I never saw both options listed at GC after monitoring it almost daily since March... both were mentioned in the specification, but the item listing was for the 5" only. And the 6.5" inventory from other sources (Dale's, Vic's, Sweetwater, American Music, etc.) seemed to arrive and vanish within days of each other about two weeks ago. Sam Ash did show both sizes in stock up through yesterday, but as of this morning, both there appear to be gone as well.
If you don't receive the 6.5", here's some recent experience that may convince you the 5” is a worthy contender...
About a month ago, I did a side-by-side comparison of the 5" and 6.5" 40th Birch model with medium tuning and no muffling at GC. Among 5 of us there (3 drummers, 1 recording engineer, 1 guitarist), everyone agreed both had a great “crack” and the 5” was a excellent sounding drum, but the unanimous favorite was the 6.5" due to its more full-bodied tonality and “throaty” sound. The versatility of the crack and throatiness (if you will ;-) of the 6.5” Birch was very appealing.
This made me more energized about the Bell Brass (BB) model so I asked the dept. mgr. if he could get the 5” one listed on the site in the store and call Tama to see if the 6.5” was also available. Turned out that Hoshino USA only had two remaining 5” BB and none of the 6.5” left in inventory (in Bensalem, PA) at that point. Mind you, this is mid-April for models that were just released in April. Apparently only 30 of each BB version were made to be distributed within the U.S. and all other units had already shipped to retailers.
Several days later the 5” BB model arrived and while waiting for the mgr. to pull it from receiving, I got a cell call and stepped into the cymbal room to avoid disrupting other customers. Deep into conversation several minutes later, I heard this beautiful, fat snare sound come from across the dept. and casually looked in that direction… i.e. not expecting to see the BB. The mgr. (behind the snare) and the other staff drummer across the other side of the room were both staring wide-eyed at each other and asked, “Did that really just come from that little drum?” The sound was punchy and more “bronzy” than brassy with a controlled ringing outside the sweet spot and a nice crack with accents and rim shots. Physically it was fairly heavy and the fit and finish was quite impressive as you would anticipate. Succinctly put, the 5” BB was not only tasty like the 5” Birch, but full-bodied and capable of power similar the 6.5” Birch… albeit in its own way.
I then found a number of YouTube videos from user “bellbrass” and his newly acquired 6.5” BB which I found very beneficial. Three clips that nicely highlight the 6.5” sound at low, medium and high tunings without any other instruments are:
Low:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALcD-9oy0y
Medium:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcwlrmnfNqw
High:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tC4iHnhbfeE
Additionally there are several other videos of him playing it with his 3-piece Gretsch kit (all tuned very open) along to songs from Rush, Journey, ELP and Santana so you can also listen to it in context with other instruments.
From these, you can hear the 6.5” is quite impressive with a voice and strengths all its own. To me, the contrast between the 5” and 6.5” Bell Brass isn’t as significant as the Birch with respect to a full-bodied, throaty sound. The 5” Birch is more noticeably shallow sounding than the 6.5” Birch whereas both BB models seem to have a closer depth and breadth in tone. The 5” BB just seems to have more of a controlled, “bronzy” tone (i.e. less open and “brassy” ring) than the 6.5” does. Given this, one could certainly state the 6.5” may be able to be muffled to more closely match the 5” and would therefore be more versatile… which very well may be true, I just can’t validate it not having both side by side.
In summary, the 5” BB is articulate with significant power potential and a versatile snare for many genres and environments. And for my needs, the 6.5” Birch and 5” Bell Brass would be my humble selections from these two series.
Which brings to mind… has anyone tested any of the 40th Rosewood models? I believe GC has the 5” and wonder how it compares to the 6.5” and 8” versions…