If you had your choice, which kit would it be?
I play Oaks and really like them, thinking about a collectors kit in maple but never played them. Any of you have hands on with both?
Thanks, Drummers
I've played them both. Oaks really cut through the mix. They are LOUD. I found them to be a bit harsh for my tastes. Kit was nice though. Good quality hardware etc. Limited finishes.
I have really mixed feelings about DW collectors. To me they sound a bit too muted, especially with the stock heads. It's almost like they're trying to make a maple kit sound like birch. They really should give some options with the heads I feel. I think DW's are kind of a one trick pony. Some people love them but they're not my cup of tea. Lugs can be a turn off for some even though it's a given that they're high quality kits.
As far as high end kits go, I find Sonor, Tama, Gretsch to be more versatile than DW's. To be honest, I'd rather have Ludwig Classic Maple than a DW Collectors. That's me though. YMMV.