What Makes Keith Moon a Legendary Drummer?

GetAgrippa

Platinum Member
Keith Moon is a legend because he played with a legendary band called "The Who" ? Now there is "The Guess Who" and guess what I had to look up Garry Peterson. So it must be more than just being the drummer in a successful band huh?
 

wraub

Well-known member
On paper, few things about The Who "work"... The drummer keeps time in the loosest sounding way, the bass player plays the roots along with everything else, the guitarist wants to be a classical musician and the singer is in a loud blues band.
That is works so well is almost kind of amazing ;)

The fact that few drummers (and bands) can replicate the method is why The Who endures, imo.
 

MrInsanePolack

Platinum Member
Current youtube'er norms demand that participants quantify and rank everything. It's a societal problem that we're currently looking into a solution for.
Give them real jobs, let them rank themselves amongst their coworkers. This crap will stop real fast. Once they realize the only thing they are good at making are lists that dont matter, they will move on. There is going to be a lot of tears, whining, and disappointment. It's good for personal growth. Now pull up your pants, comb your hair, and do something productive for once.
 

Icetech

Gold Member
good vid, i'm kind of surprised how dead the toms sound without any muffling on them (that i could see) they fit perfect for the songs though..
 

ToneT

Well-known member
He mastered the art of sending explosives down toilets, sometimes blowing up the piping as well! Jeez!
 

Bo Eder

Platinum Member
Agreed. But if it weren't for Moon's playing, many of us—even hardcore music fans like us, and certainly the larger population—wouldn't have heard those songs; his playing (and Entwhistle's) was absolutely integral to their success, both artistic and commercial. (Strange as it is to those of who raised on classic rock and AOR, the Who were never the sales behemoths of the Beatles or even the Rolling Stones, never having a #1 song or LP, and only a single Top 10 single—Moon's playing [and perhaps his off-stage behavior] is absolutely every bit as big a reason for the Who's fame in the 60s and 70s as Townshend's amazing songs.)
I concur that The Who as a whole package is important, but at the same time, the reason they were playing anywhere is because of the songs being written. It’s the same with every drummer: no music, no playing.
 

someguy01

Well-known member
Current youtube'er norms demand that participants quantify and rank everything. It's a societal problem that we're currently looking into a solution for.
This is a problem that has plagued mankind since the dawn of time. We still label, rank, and pool people based on semantics and society does not benefit from it at all. Let me know if you manage to find a solution, because we'd like you to tackle homelessness and world peace after that.
 

brushes

Well-known member
From a drummers perspective, my choice of top songs would be - in no particular order:

Bargain
My wife
Overture
Who are you
Love is coming over me
Won't get fooled again
The real me
Young man blues
Water
Doctor Jimmy
Sparks
Underture
Picture of Lily
Go to the mirror

And I could list a few more great songs...
 

michaelg

Member
Moon played some great stuff with The Who. His sound & feel were fantastic on many recordings. Yes he went off the rails and very sadly lost it at some point but remember when he was good he was a brilliant and a fantastic entertainer to boot.

Underneath all the drug abuse and flamboyance he was a wonderful musician and he should be remembered as such.

I present exhibit A which in my view is breathtaking


And what he laid down in the studio here is fantastic and again serves the music so well. Not too many men could sustain that level of energy for 8 odd minutes. glorious music and performance.

 
Last edited:

bud7h4

Silver Member
His drumming in the Who is very up front, prominent. Far from great, but impossible not to listen to.
 

Iristone

Well-known member
His attitude.
As for stylistic origin, I think someone (his daughter?) said that his chops came from Gene Krupa and other big band drummers. So maybe he actually was working hard, both on his playing and on his appearance of not working hard at all. 😂
 
Top