What you are saying is that there are critical components of the sound that are buried under the ambient sound. So if you have to listen in such a controlled situation does it matter?From a crappy cell phone video? In a very loud room at NAMM? No.
In person inside a studio where you can hear all the nuances? You bet!
I’m not certain I’d be 10/10 every time, but in this scenario I’m sure I’d be close.