Make a mistake performing? Don't bother making a frowny face.

Jeremy Bender

Platinum Member
A study observing the psychological effect on the listener that observes a performer making a mistake...


Why Every Performer Needs a Good Poker Face​



AOh14GhfDnyV1aYCQhEATnHr5POc8SJNF8ZfaqPWUaCxDw=s40


Noa Kageyama, Ph.D. <noa@bulletproofmusician.com> Unsubscribe​





8-T7GZl9_Tyb050MC1mmIOtwWOhDhJjcsrzfQ6_8BCSvrsM5W5VH3FDfJhjTsjkiSVmqOGPbWk8XrlxeHAbN3QHqIHC0bm8KHz9vbQB6GzyhZOYgd6I0XYolUMYp6EwVOrKZfas=s0-d-e1-ft

RM7W76SmmgF1QPdj0nJxmsazqlNzSMRy6z-vO3NfIJTBQyqj3-qqYOAsMZFS-hvIu1a7hg-XpoIfgW0Pkmac095AkPEaVEspna8FRTyT5plvjnoQ84aDgUy3A0kcLy5TXgYoHzjvEvHt1DO2xrPL8OKgVJ_9wFpqP_00=s0-d-e1-ft

Why Every Performer Needs a Good Poker Face​

by Noa Kageyama
My daughter loves card games. And what I enjoy most about playing with her, is how completely transparent she is. Anytime she gets dealt a good hand, or picks up a special card, it’s written all over her face. Her eyes light up, and I know something bad is about to happen to me.
In time, maybe she’ll develop a better poker a better poker face, but for now it’s pretty cute.
And maybe not all bad, because when it comes to performing, research suggests that this sort of emotional expressivity is an important part of communicating from the stage. But…there’s a flip side. Where we frown and scowl, or express frustration when the performance isn’t going well.
We’ve all had teachers tell us to avoid making such faces when we’ve made a mistake, but really, as long as we sound great, how big a deal is it really?

The visual impact of what we do on stage​

A number of studies in the last few decades have shed more light on questions like this (like this one that caused quite a stir), suggesting that what we see affects our evaluation of a performance more than we might like to think. And researchers George Waddell and Aaron Williamon at the Royal College of Music’s Centre for Performance Science recently conducted a study to look at two specific visual aspects of a performance – first impressions, and facial expressions in response to mistakes.

Same performance, but with a few tweaks​

53 musicians and 52 non-musicians were recruited, and randomly assigned to one of several groups. Each group was to watch and evaluate video of the same performance of Chopin’s Aeolian HarpEtude, but with a few slight modifications made to each video.
Participants in Group #1 and Group #2 watched an error-free performance. However, while Group #1 saw the pianist walk on stage confidently, Group #2 saw the pianist walk on stage with poor stage presence (hands in pockets, barely looking at the audience, not smiling, etc.).
Groups #3 and #4’s videos both used the “good” stage entrance, but in their videos, the pianist makes a pretty major mistake. Midway through the piece, he flat-out stops and fumbles around for a moment before resuming the performance – noticeable even to the non-musicians. In Group #3’s video however, the pianist makes a face, shakes his head, and looks frustrated in response to the mistake, while in Group #4’s video, he has no discernible reaction to the mistake at all.

Rating the performance​

The participants were asked to rate the quality of the performance, as if they were judging a competition.
But to get a sense of how quickly we form first impressions, and how our impressions change over the course of a performance, the researchers used an interesting “continuous” rating system. Where instead of waiting until the very end to ask participants for a score, participants were allowed to rate the performance from the very beginning, making adjustments to their score from moment to moment, as their opinion of his playing changed.
ZoH0LJ1nbjjCJIHSsUkIxziANbDKebJfMgfIrK7rnKDgiz9054yrwyG25TbevEG63vh11Fe_houd3y8neIDxWqfI82hzH9vDUkq9JYewpu_d3afu4y5QPQ7y_QERg42OGTB0EOU=s0-d-e1-ft

From Waddell, G., & Williamon, A. (2017). Eye of the Beholder: Stage Entrance Behavior and Facial Expression Affect Continuous Quality Ratings in Music Performance. Frontiers in Psychology, 8.
So how much does a performer’s stage entrance, and facial reactions matter?

The impact of a poor stage entrance​

Walking out on stage with poor stage presence did have an immediate impact.
For one, both musicians and non-musicians were much quicker to judge the performance, giving it a score 8 seconds into the performance. Those who saw the “good” stage entrance didn’t give the performance an initial rating until 18.52 seconds in.
Two, the pianist’s poor stage entrance totally affected his score – at least amongst the musicians, who gave his playing an initial rating of 34.91 (out of 70). Curiously, the non-musicians didn’t seem to mind his poor stage entrance. They gave him an initial score of 47.30, which was on par with what he got from non-musicians in the other groups who saw his good stage entrance.

But wait – that’s not the end of it!​

But even the musicians didn’t seem to hold his poor stage entrance against him for long. By the 25-second mark of his performance, his performance rating had already recovered and was on par with the score he got from musicians who watched the video with his good stage entrance.
So while first impressions may have some impact and shouldn’t be ignored, perhaps the way we walk out on stage isn’t quite as influential as we may have thought. Or at least, it’s something we can overcome as long as our playing is at a high level and we exhibit good stage presence while playing.
So what about mistakes, and making faces in response? Is it possible that this too is not as big a deal as people say it is?

Making faces​

As you can imagine, making a very audible mistake led to an immediate drop in performance ratings. But the magnitude of the drop depended on whether it was accompanied by a face or not.
Participants who heard the mistake, but saw video of the pianist looking blissfully unaware of the memory slip, dropped his rating by 7.43 points (relative to the error-free performance).
Those who not only heard the mistake, but saw the pianist shaking his head and looking frustrated dropped his rating by 19.20 points (relative to the error-free performance).
So obviously, making a mistake is not great, but expressing frustration apparently makes the mistake seem waaay worse.
Which is interesting, but there was actually something even more intriguing to come out of the data.

Audiences may be surprisingly forgiving​

The musicians who watched the video where the pianist displayed no facial reaction to the mistake gave his performance a final score of 48.55 – which is identical to their initial rating of 48.55. The non-musicians’ scores were similar – a final score of 46.00 and an initial score of 45.00.
So in other words, the mistake did not affect the final score that musicians and non-musicians gave his performance. It appears that they either forgot or “forgave” the mistake by the time he reached the end of the piece!
But this was not the case for those who saw him make a face in response to the mistake. These musicians’ initial rating (44.00) dropped in response to the mistake and stayed down, ending at 35.50. Same for the non-musicians (45.50 initial rating; 36.50 final rating).

Why did this happen?​

So why are both musicians and non-musicians more likely to forgive a mistake when it isn’t accompanied by a look of frustration?
The authors note that when we interpret facial expressions, we don’t just intuit the person’s current mood, but also make generalizations about more stable characteristics and traits. So when we see a musician expressing frustration at making a mistake, instead of interpreting this as a random mistake, the expression of frustration may lead us to conclude that such mistakes are habitual, and that this is a musician who routinely struggles with consistency.

Take action​

As usual, it seems that our teachers were totally right. Making a mistake is not the end of the world, and an audience is often much more forgiving than we give them credit for being – so long as we can keep our face from giving us away and ruining the experience for them.
Would an audition committee or competition jury be as forgiving? That’s hard to say, but it’s probably a safe bet that maintaining your poker face is a better way to go, no matter how many mistakes you find yourself making on stage (or alternately, I guess you could make sure everything is a “hole-in-one,” ala Happy Gilmore).

Dig a little deeper​

If you’d like to geek out about this some more, the full paper and all five videos are online here:
Eye of the Beholder: Stage Entrance Behavior and Facial Expression Affect Continuous Quality Ratings in Music Performance (paper)
Supplementary Material (videos, etc.)
Or, if you only have time for the highlights, the researchers have distilled the videos down to 88 seconds here:
Does stage behaviour matter?

Found this article helpful? Here are two more things you might like:
  • Practice challenges: If practice has been feeling a little stale, change things up a bit with these 7-day practice plans, and make this your most productive week of practice yet.
  • Online mental skills course: Learn how to overcome nerves and become a more confident and effective performer in the Bulletproof Musician home-study course, where you'll develop six skills that athletes use to perform their best when it matters most.
 
Last edited:

drumnut87

Well-known member
if me or my guitarist make a mistake we look at each other, laugh, make a FNERR kind of face, and carry on with the rest of the tune/night, we dont let it bother us as best we can :)
 

Bozozoid

Well-known member
I have a DVD of Bruce Hornsby live with Jerry Garcia sitting in on across the river. Jerry made a big blunder on a ride that was obvious. Bruce had a look like....what the?whoa!. I was hoping Jerry didn't see it..i felt bad.
 

Mastiff

Senior Member
Slightly tangential, but I saw King Crimson recently and was very close to Gavin Harrison. During a solo-ish elaborate part he lost a stick and snatched another one out so fast that you really had to be paying close attention to notice. I really didn't hear anything that sounded out of place either. Very cool and professional.
 

Cmdr. Ross

Silver Member
My old band, if one of us made a mistake, the others would give an approving look and perhaps yell "yeah!" as though it were intentionally avant-garde.
There's a quote somewhere that says something along the lines of, "Once is a mistake, twice is improvisation".
 

ColdFusion

Member
This is an interesting topic. I can add a bit of anecdotal support.

Despite what we may be feeling in the moment we make a mistake, there is only upside to not being so sensitive about mistakes that you let it show on your face.

I saw it for myself in one of my own playthrough videos. The CY-5 hihat pad can be tricky to play sensitively. At one point I may have played a flatish 16th note during a busy hihat section. Under my stick it felt like what I call a mistake. But in the playback it didn't really sound like anything was amiss.

What WAS amiss was that suddenly in the video you can see me start shaking my head, like a boxer who caught a jab. This is a superfluous, distracting gesture. Like, who am I making excuses to? In the middle of a song!

But let's be charitable to eachother. I think we all know why we do it.

It's in case there's some drum hawks in the audience, and we want them to know that "Yeah, I noticed it." and also "It's totally not like me to make mistakes bro.", 😁
 

BruceW

Senior Member
I really am trying to stop doing that, making a face when I mess up. I do it less now, but I still catch myself.

Funny thing is our bass player does it too, but he has the advantage of turning back to the audience, looking at me, when he does it. I'm always laughing at him, so folks might figure it out, but they might think we're just having fun. Which I guess is true in both cases. 😉 But he can get away with it easier, while I'm facing the audience the whole time...
 

Dr_Watso

Platinum Member
I admit I do make a face when I do something really bad, or that should have been easy, but for the most part I can let the little stuff slide right off the ol' back
 

Al Strange

Well-known member
I think my face is a mistake and my playing acknowledges this…:unsure: One of my biggest heroes is Rod Morgenstein who constantly gurns whilst playing perfectly executed beat displacements; very misleading for those who like to spot a mistake. The king has to be Mick Fleetwood; now that’s a mistake face if ever I saw one! :unsure: 😂
 

The Shepherd

Well-known member
They are not mistakes, it's me trying out a new jazz rhythm.
 
Top