The result can be summed up in one phrase: Bull in a China shop
Overall, I had a good time talking with and especially playing percussion with the other drummers - all young (I'm old enough to be their Dad) - they had a circle of congas, so I started the drum conversation with a simple supportive pattern so they could all join in - it really was great, it shows the brotherhood that we innately have. No egos or bad behavior.
Simple points:
- The other guys were more indy-type hipster drummers
- They brought vintage snares
- I brought a modded double-pedal (trick universal shaft and Tama wood beaters).
That should tell you everything
I was the only guy with a double-pedal.
I thought each guy played more musically and dynamically than I did. When it was my turn, my planned solo was based around a Jill Scott funky/swinging bassline that would morph into brutal Pantera double bass patterns with some Chris Adler/Tommy Aldridge metal chops thrown in. When I got done, the other drummers gave me way too many compliments! I complimented their playing as well. My wife said I was brutal and twice the volume of everyone else, the MC said I was the most brutal he's seen, but I didn't get picked, which is fine because like I said, they were more dynamic and musical, I was just an old-school hybrid metal drummer throwing down. I didn't expect to be picked, and the judges were indy rock types (a little snobby, and that's ok), BUT to be told I was the most brutal was all I needed
It made my day, I was very happy.. A few people in the audience came up to me and said it was ridiculous that I wasn't picked, but I told them why I
shouldn't be - so, a good experience all around.
There was one guy who played excellent funk grooves - very open, he had the best timing/meter out of everyone - the other guys were not. I found that to be a bit alarming that it was just me and this other guy (he didn't get picked either) that could actually carry a band - playing solid timing, even authoritative patterns, defining the song. The other kids were messing up 8th note patterns, triplets and even some simple rolls that you could hear were not solid, missing notes, dragged or rushed. I recommended to them practicing more with percussive backgrounds or with click-tracks, but I think the best advice I gave to them was to get more involved with bands and being self-aware of your timing "in real-time" as it would eventually build confidence and help improve driving a band or establishing a groove. Seriously, I worry about some kids today as mentioned in other threads (YouTube technical vs. leading a band).
In summary:
1) Bucket list item completed.
2) Reaffirmed my belief that all drummers are bros.
3) These types of contests are really meant for younger guys to get more exposure - I truly hope some of these kids move on to be pros.
4) Learning experience for me - I need to be more musical. Lessons and a new practice routine are in order...
5) The learning experiences will never end...
6) Drums = happiness!