Alesis Strata, DWe, Zildjian or Roland VAD?

classikdrummr

Well-known Member
I love the DWe system with Maple shells and Wireless , but Holy Cow!Way overpriced.The zildjian looks promising, but again, overpriced. I am leaning towards the Strata. The Samples sound amazing. Plus its less $$$ then the others. This will be a practice kit only to save the sanity of my new Neighbors( i just Moved) The Roland VAD 507 has great reviews and seems to be used for Gigging regularly .The TD 27 module seems dated compared to the Strata with the Touchscreen . Please give me some feedback. I wish Tama would come up with a competing e Hybrid system.
 
Have you played any of the kits you mention? What did you think? And what's your budget for the project?
 
I don't know if the problem has been fixed but there were numerous reports of the Strata Prime module freezing up just after it's initial release in late spring. Personally, I am wary of the long-term reliability of Alesis components. Currently, Sweetwater has a nice deal ($1600 off) on the Roland VAD 506.
 
ive played the Roland and loved it. SAmples are good and customization is good. my budget is 7k
Buy that one then :) (not sampled kit though - synthetic models). Oh, and chuck a DTX into your shortlist. Alesis has bugs at the mo - and the pads can be a bit fragile - Yamaha or Roland for known build quality (Yamaha is multilayered samples + individual cabling, Roland is models and cable snake on most models)
 
Thank you so much for the advice. I had a Yamaha for dtx for years and it was very well built. I will stick with Yamaha or Roland. That VAD 506 deal looks good on sweetwater RN
 
Got it a couple weeks early thanks to Sweetwater! Got The Roland VAD 506 for 3k plus extra 14" cymbal trigger for $350. $1700 discount.
The best deal out there that i could find. It looks and sound s fantastic! It is actually Gig ready as is. Although i will manly use it for practice.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2704.jpg
    IMG_2704.jpg
    665.7 KB · Views: 8
  • IMG_2705.jpg
    IMG_2705.jpg
    757.3 KB · Views: 6
  • IMG_2709.jpg
    IMG_2709.jpg
    587 KB · Views: 5
  • IMG_2710.jpg
    IMG_2710.jpg
    687.6 KB · Views: 4
  • IMG_2711.jpg
    IMG_2711.jpg
    660.9 KB · Views: 7
  • IMG_2712.jpg
    IMG_2712.jpg
    779.7 KB · Views: 8
ive played the Roland and loved it. SAmples are good and customization is good. my budget is 7k
If you can afford that, I would go for a Roland TD50x with Superior Drummer or similar VST library then you get the best of both worlds and will never look back, if you don't want the Roland look you can get a Drum-Tec kit with the Roland Module (and the included samples which allow you to use only the module and are very gig ready).


Drum-Tec sells other expansions but you can create those yourself too. Just learn how to import and blend samples into the module.

The differences between the Roland module and the Alesis module are that you get much more customization with the Roland but you get the touch screen with the Alesis... sounds are subjective, I believe, no, I know you can get good usable sounds with the Roland modules if you spend the time dialing them in, same goes for Alesis which I have owned the DM5 which surprisingly has aged well.
Other differences are Roland's proven reliability (I have had a TD-11 kit for over 12 years and not a single part has failed me). Prior Alesis kits had lots of reliability issues with pads failing all the time (you certainly don't want that on a supposedly flagship kit). Granted Alesis seems to have corrected those issues, their reputation still suffers.

Another route you can go if you don't want to spend that much is buy the module with the digital pads (which drum tech also sells), buy the triggers and cymbals and convert any acoustic of your liking into your custom kit. Even doing that, you will probably still end up spending less and get exactly what you want. Jobeky also sells cymbals and drums you can use to create your kit.


That is the way I would go if I was building a kit from the ground up and had that budget.

you could end up with something like this:

 
Last edited:
If you can afford that, I would go for a Roland TD50x with Superior Drummer or similar VST library then you get the best of both worlds and will never look back, if you don't want the Roland look you can get a Drum-Tec kit with the Roland Module (and the included samples which allow you to use only the module and are very gig ready).


Drum-Tec sells other expansions but you can create those yourself too. Just learn how to import and blend samples into the module.

The differences between the Roland module and the Alesis module are that you get much more customization with the Roland but you get the touch screen with the Alesis... sounds are subjective, I believe, no, I know you can get good usable sounds with the Roland modules if you spend the time dialing them in, same goes for Alesis which I have owned the DM5 which surprisingly has aged well.
Other differences are Roland's proven reliability (I have had a TD-11 kit for over 12 years and not a single part has failed me). Prior Alesis kits had lots of reliability issues with pads failing all the time (you certainly don't want that on a supposedly flagship kit). Granted Alesis seems to have corrected those issues, their reputation still suffers.

Another route you can go if you don't want to spend that much is buy the module with the digital pads (which drum tech also sells), buy the triggers and cymbals and convert any acoustic of your liking into your custom kit. Even doing that, you will probably still end up spending less and get exactly what you want. Jobeky also sells cymbals and drums you can use to create your kit.


That is the way I would go if I was building a kit from the ground up and had that budget.

you could end up with something like this:

Great idea. I will think about a module upgrade to the TD50 in a couple months possibly. My wife may not be open to it RN though, lol
 
I love the DWe system with Maple shells and Wireless , but Holy Cow!Way overpriced.The zildjian looks promising, but again, overpriced. I am leaning towards the Strata. The Samples sound amazing. Plus its less $$$ then the others. This will be a practice kit only to save the sanity of my new Neighbors( i just Moved) The Roland VAD 507 has great reviews and seems to be used for Gigging regularly .The TD 27 module seems dated compared to the Strata with the Touchscreen . Please give me some feedback. I wish Tama would come up with a competing e Hybrid system.
You can’t beat Roland’s reliability and we all know Alesis still has a bad reputation when it comes to it. If you are able to find honest strata reviews you will see that it is not as good as they want you to believe, if you want the shiny screen you are much better off with a Pearl mimic module which still at that price doesn’t offer positional sensing!. If you were going The Roland route a TD 27 with Steven Slate drums or Superior drummer offers much more bang for the buck than the Strata prime, and it does offer positional sensing and comes with the 3 digital pads.
 
I wouldn't rush into anything now as the next Roland flagship (TD-71) is just around the corner... But if you want Superior Drummer, it's 25% off this month, that's not happening too often. Though if I had the 506, my first priority would be the VH14d...
 
Back
Top