Anybody switch from double to single?

  • Thread starter drumming sort of person
  • Start date
Most music isn't written for double pedal, that's the crucial point. If someone only plays double that will limit their repertoire to music written/adapted for it. In a real gig situation unless you were in a deathmetal band you wouldn't be on the double pedals all night.

Having said that Louis Bellson adapted doubles into jazz and Ginger Baker adapted them into blues. I thought both sounded OK but of course the music was crafted for that purpose. So yeah, you have to be selective about it.

Don't play Silent Night on the double bass and crash cymbals.
 
Of course it's a personal and a comfort issue. I played double for years, and got quite proficient at it (for the gigs I was in at the time). I still have the slave in its case...just never feel the need to bust it out anymore. On the practicality side, I just don't play the type of music that demands a double pedal anymore. Why the hell should I carry around extra gear that I probably won't use?

Ok, see this makes more sense and should have been said in the first place. Sonny if you go back and read what you said originally you can't tell me that kind of comment wouldn't strike someone as a bit odd.

I still say I don't quite understand how having the extra pedal next to your hi hat pedal keeps you from constantly controlling the hi hat while playing music or beats with just the main pedal? Also like what was said above by Drumming: "Without the double pedal you are forced to develop your right foot." I don't understand that at all. Are you saying you don't have the mental discipline to keep your left foot off of the double pedal while you develop your right foot skills with just the main pedal? It's not like trying to keep from smoking or doing drugs, you're just keeping your left foot on the hi hat pedal instead of the slave pedal lol! Seriously, I don't understand that reasoning. Practicing my right foot skills is no more or no less effective with or without that slave pedal. The mentality of not being able to work on your right foot skills because there is a second bass drum pedal there is just very odd thinking. Also with the rest of your post, I don't understand how an extra pedal next to your hi hat keeps you from controlling the hi hat the right way when just using the main pedal of a double pedal? Do you or anyone else see where I'm going with this?

Whether the slave pedal is there or not should have NO affect on how well you can play or control the hi hat while just using the main pedal! Ok fine, you don't need the slave anymore and put it away but having it there should have no affect, NONE, on how well you play the hats while just using the main pedal of a double pedal!
 
Do you or anyone else see where I'm going with this?

Considering you asked. Other than the fact that his reasons for tossing out the double pedal don't cut it for you, I haven't got a clue.

Is the fact that he no longer wants to invest the time and effort into developing his double pedal skills really worth three posts of ranting angst?
 
Considering you asked. Other than the fact that his reasons for tossing out the double pedal don't cut it for you, I haven't got a clue.

Is the fact that he no longer wants to invest the time and effort into developing his double pedal skills really worth three posts of ranting angst?

Who said anything about his double pedal skills? Also I'm not ranting over his post, just the opinions I've seen about double pedals on the net in general.

All I am saying about his post is that it's odd to say that you can't constantly control the hi hat nor get the sounds out of the hi hats he wants because of the slave pedal being next to the hi hat stand. If that's the case how do 1000's of other drummers do everything and then some with their hats and with a double pedal setup? It was just a very odd comment as to why he would dump the double pedal. If you set them up properly it should have NO affect on being able to play the hats the way you want.

I don't care if he doesn't want to use them anymore. I just found his reason for making the change odd is all. There is absolutely NO reason why you can't control the hi hat the way you want to just because there is a slave pedal next to the hi hat stand.
 
I tried a while ago to stop using my double pedal and I just cant leave it at home for gigs. The studio kits I use, practice or recording have single pedals and I don't miss it. Its just something in my head that I fear I will need it for something and it wont be there. Classic rock songs we play don't use it but I always use it on endings.
 
There is absolutely NO reason why you can't control the hi hat the way you want to just because there is a slave pedal next to the hi hat stand.

I reckon you're reading a hell of a lot more into his post than was expressed though. Thought he just said he prefers to control the high hat all the time?

I just like controlling the high hat all the time.

To me that just says that he can no longer be arsed with a slave pedal. Not that he can't play because of its very existence.


I'm not much fazed either way to be honest. But you did ask the question, remember. I merely responded. From where I'm sitting it appears you're vehemently countering a point he never made. And as such, I don't see where you're going with this.
 
Look man, I have no particular use for the slave part of my double bass pedal. It's extra crap to carry around for really no reason...for me. I have not said double bass drum pedals are useless or worthless. Quite the contrary....but,

1) it does take up room next to my foot, and like many drummers I like things to be just so. I am used to the fact that I no longer have the slave pedal there, (in my way?)
2) I do not play any music that requires a double bass. That is, I can manage just fine without it.
3) in one of my bands I lead sing about one third of the songs....call it a set. I sing backing in my other bands as well. Do I feel the need to complicate things? No.
4) I was only quickly responding to the OP's thread....and the very truth was spoken when I stated that "I like to control the high hat ALL the time". It's a subtle thing...for me, really, as I'm the one who gets to hear it exactly how I want it in the drivers seat.

Anyway.....meh
 
I guess I can understand that. In a way, that slave pedal to some in the way or not, can make it seem like an 11th finger when you're only supposed to have 10 lol. :)

Seems I may of read too much into what was said. I meant nothing personal with my comments, so with that I have given my thoughts on this topic and will bow out.

Sorry all for getting in deep with my opinions.
 
Also like what was said above by Drumming: "Without the double pedal you are forced to develop your right foot." I don't understand that at all. Are you saying you don't have the mental discipline to keep your left foot off of the double pedal while you develop your right foot skills with just the main pedal?

No, but there are times when you're in the middle of a very intense section of the music, and it's crying out for some double bass work, and if you don't have the double pedal, you will find a way to satisfy the music without it, and that usually means extra effort with the one pedal.

Why use a double if you're just going to ignore it? If it's there, and the music calls for it, I'm going to play it. If it's not there, and the music calls for it, you find another way.

In a practice setup, sure, you may as well leave it there and work on both single and double approaches. I'm talking about actual performing situations. There is absolutely a mental aspect to whether you have it there or not, and your playing changes. Try it and you'll see what I mean.
 
I like my double bass pedal. Opens up all kinds of new vocabulary (kkrlrl, kklrlr, kkkklrlr, kkkrlr, etc ,etc). Same with independence stuff. 1/16 down there and paradiddle on top , etc, etc. could go on and on. The more the possibilities , the better .

Exactly.

I wouldn't play with only one stick...

Limitations - right off the bat.

I mean - you don't tape your right hand on a specific cymbal or drum. Why would you limit either of your feet to a specific cymbal or drum?
 
Why would you limit either of your feet to a specific cymbal or drum?

Using that logic, I would expect you to add a remote hi-hat pedal to your right, as well as another remote pedal to work the additional bass drum you'll want to add, not to mention a couple of timpani behind you. Why limit yourself?

Limiting yourself is one of the greatest ways to develop.
 
Using that logic, I would expect you to add a remote hi-hat pedal to your right, as well as another remote pedal to work the additional bass drum you'll want to add, not to mention a couple of timpani behind you. Why limit yourself?

Limiting yourself is one of the greatest ways to develop.
lol! I love it.

I've actually done the remote hi-hat already... I ran out of room on the right side of my floor. I now just leave the second hat fixed on right side just to the right of my ride.

I don't do things behind me anymore - can't reach 'em. I love rows of stuff to hit. Look at Neil Peart - has an entire second kit behind him (although he just repeats the same thing from one side to the other).

I cannot argue against the development perspective. I've done weird things to improve my technique. The most fun was reversing my entire kit for 2 months - playing lefty. I'll just do things just to see what happens.

This week, I'm redoing rudiments with my youngest son on a drum pad. He said he wants to "play like daddy". So I picked up a pair of 7A's and a stool for him, and we're going shopping for pads.
 
I love the feeling of sitting behind a huge drum set, with two bass drums, at least six toms, ten or more cymbals, a gong, and some electronics. Those days are over for me though. I don't have the time or patience to set it all up (let alone transport it), and I don't know of any bands that would warrant it, let alone stages that would accomodate them.
 
I own a 5 string bass and feel the same way about the B string that you feel about the slave pedal but when there was finally a song my band played that could use the low string, it was worth all the trouble of dealing with a bigger neck/fretboard.

The slave pedal can be fit into just about any genre. When you don't need to use it, don't. When it can be worked in to improve a song, work it in. That's the beauty of playing percussion... limitless opportunity to use different tools and sounds to your advantage.

Just my $.02.
 
You people are missing the point of my original post. I fully realize that you don't need to use the pedal just because it's there, and that it offers more options, but I was specifically asking to hear about others' experience going from one to two and what that did to their playing.
 
I play double pedal for my heavier gigs and single for my lighter ones. It's like a guitarist using different rigs for different gigs.

The different setup makes me approach the drums a little differently. Neither way is "limiting yourself". You still have all your limbs and can use them creatively.

I have a thought-provoking comment for all of us here. When I see phrases like "the slave pedal can be fit into just about any genre", I get nervous because there are actually very few genres in which double pedal actually works. Certainly not most jazz, country, pop, blues, latin, hip hop and R & B songs. I mean, just listen to the music that most people listen to and try to find the double bass.

If it's not high energy rock, fusion, metal or a solo, how much double bass is there in contemporary music? Not much.

I can totally see why a drummer might not even bother with double bass and not feel as if he was limiting himself.
 
You people are missing the point of my original post. I fully realize that you don't need to use the pedal just because it's there, and that it offers more options, but I was specifically asking to hear about others' experience going from one to two and what that did to their playing.

When I went to double bass (after 10 years without one), I woke up as a drummer.

Changed my entire musical outlook and future. I'm pissed I didn't get one sooner. May have helped advance my abilities. Can't imagine how good I would have been if I had started with it (or how much different/versatile I may have been).
 
There's definitely a fun factor to having the options of a double pedal...if you can establish some ease with it.. I own all double pedals but rarely set them up that way. It's used more as a crutch most usually and I think it's more intriguing to play simply and still draw people in....
 
When I first started playing drums 20 years ago, I almost immediately bought a 2nd bass drum and another pedal. Thank Lars for that......

After playing drums on and off and a long layoff, I returned to drums about 2 years ago and decided to go "back to basics" and run a single pedal.

I feel like I'm better now than ever on drums due to this change. I feel the groove more and feel like my time is infinitely more steady. I've never had a lesson and I'll admit that I don't keep time on the hi-hat with my left foot but I just feel more solid overall on the set and it translated upstairs to my hands as well.

I hear some nice double-bass parts that other drummers throw into some simple songs that our band covers and I'll admit that I think "Damn that sounded awesome!" But overall I plan on sticking with single pedal for the rest of my drum "career." (And by career, I mean my typical rock cover band playing small bars.)
 
As to the OP question way back there....
I just stopped feeling like I wanted it. I had 2 bass drums for about 8 or 9 years (single before that), then a Camco double back in 90. Used it for some years and then just didn't want to anymore.

I didn't do the extended "dugga dugga dugga"or speedy stuff in my bands. I used it more like Ginger Baker, and how Carmine used it on some of his stuff. I was into Tommy Aldridge too.

My tastes in playing changed, along with what the bands songs needed--which was whatever I wanted to play that fit haha! the stuff they started doing just didn't need anything I couldn't do with one foot.

I've toyed with the idea of using one again, but, I just don't feel it.

I can do a lot with my one foot anyway, and it sounds cooler to me that way, or between a tom and the bas drum for that kind of pattern.
I also like not having to use one for doing something that sounds"cool" in the drummy sort of way. I've worked on my foot, and like what I've achieved, and it feels right for me to just have a single pedal.
 
Back
Top