haredrums
Silver Member
Hi Guys,
Some of you may know that the name of my blog is "The Melodic Drummer", and this is something that I have been thinking about and trying to develop a lot in my own playing. One question that I get from both non-musicians and musicians alike is, "What makes a drum solo melodic?". I think that this question is actually a really difficult and interesting one, and I have posted an in-depth reply on my blog at:
http://haredrums.blogspot.com/2011/09/max-roach-melodic-architecture-and.html
Let me summarize my idea. Using the classic example of "For Big Sid" by Max Roach, I broke down Max's approach to melodic soloing into two basic ideas, architecture and phrasing. By melodic architecture I mean using the overall structures of a melody, in this case the AABA form and the head-solo-head format for the entire song. And by phrasing I mean the smaller scale elements that combine to make a melodic phrase, in this case call and response, use of space, and repetition.
By using these two ideas, Max creates a feeling of melody throughout his solo. There are obviously other ways of playing the drums melodically, for example drummers like Ari Hoenig and Jeff Hamilton often play melodies with almost explicit pitches, but my feeling is that this approach of Max's is the basis for everything else.
I would love to get everyone's feedback on this idea. Do you guys try solo melodically? Do you think this is a useful approach? What are some of your favorite examples of melodic drumming? Are there other elements of melodic drumming that you think are more important than the ones I listed?
Some of you may know that the name of my blog is "The Melodic Drummer", and this is something that I have been thinking about and trying to develop a lot in my own playing. One question that I get from both non-musicians and musicians alike is, "What makes a drum solo melodic?". I think that this question is actually a really difficult and interesting one, and I have posted an in-depth reply on my blog at:
http://haredrums.blogspot.com/2011/09/max-roach-melodic-architecture-and.html
Let me summarize my idea. Using the classic example of "For Big Sid" by Max Roach, I broke down Max's approach to melodic soloing into two basic ideas, architecture and phrasing. By melodic architecture I mean using the overall structures of a melody, in this case the AABA form and the head-solo-head format for the entire song. And by phrasing I mean the smaller scale elements that combine to make a melodic phrase, in this case call and response, use of space, and repetition.
By using these two ideas, Max creates a feeling of melody throughout his solo. There are obviously other ways of playing the drums melodically, for example drummers like Ari Hoenig and Jeff Hamilton often play melodies with almost explicit pitches, but my feeling is that this approach of Max's is the basis for everything else.
I would love to get everyone's feedback on this idea. Do you guys try solo melodically? Do you think this is a useful approach? What are some of your favorite examples of melodic drumming? Are there other elements of melodic drumming that you think are more important than the ones I listed?