Most recorded kick drums these days have a crazy amount of studio effects on them - things such as EQ, gate, compression, enveloping (making the attack more noticable, in this case), and all those sorts of things. And in other cases, the kick drum will be replaced by a kick sample. So to get that sound out of an unprocessed kick drum is going to take some experimentation.
The best thing I can say is try a hard (wood) beater with some sort of impact pad. I know Vinnie Paul used a quarter on his kick drums way back in the day (granted, his kicks aren't nearly the same sound), and you might be interested in the Danmar metal pads.
I hope that helps.