I've got a RocnSoc and a Pork Pie throne. Both are very comfortable and are the saddle style with the spiral height adjustments. While the cushion on the Pork Pie is more comfortable (and I like the color better) the stupid thing squeaks like crazy and I can't figure out how to set it up to swivel without adjusting the height. On the other hand, the RocnSoc makes no sound and I can tighten the cushion to the stem so that it's loose enough to swivel, but still tight enough to not fall off the stem if I pick it up by the seat.
Am I missing something with the Pork pie? I've got to sell one and am having a hard time deciding which to sell.