I liked a lot of the bands you mentioned, I used to love "Radar Love" from Golden Earring and most of Led Zep albums.
Now, back to your heads, given the type of music you're playing a Remo Emperor for the batter side and a Remo ambassador on the resonnance side of you toms and floor toms is a popular combo (or Evans G2 over Evans G1, or Aquarian Response 2 over Aquarian Classic Clear if you want to try a similar combo from a different brand of heads).
You can have coated batter heads that I mentioned above, they'll give you a slightly lower and darker pitch if you're after that type of sound.
A Remo Controlled Sound (CS) with a white dot in the center should give you a nice "crack" as a snare batter head.
For the bass drum, you can try an Aquarin Superkick II for the batter side with an Aquarian Regulator on the front, with good tuning, you won't need any muffling devices, as these heads have already a design to cut the overtones.
This is only a suggestion, the best way to do this is trial and error, try to learn the technicalities and likely applications of the designs of the heads available on the market, it's like shampoo, so many different type for so many different hair, ha ha
Visit the leaders website, Remo, Evans, Aquarian, they all have some kind of explanation of their product, charts of sound, samples etc.
Good luck...