Funny, a few weeks ago I was in the same dilemma as you, even down to coated/clear G2's.
I went with the coated, and I'm never going back.
The coated heads in general have NO plastic sound whatsoever, along with being warmer and rounder in general.
They make drums sound more like...well, drums.
The G2's are miraculous coated, on everything from my 10" to my 16".
They rumble on the floors and sing on the racks. Just very round, warm, deep when needed, and sing beautifully in other situations. My 10" has a gorgeous ring to it, I honestly could listen to it for hours.
Go for the Coated G2's.