No.
On smaller toms (8/10/12) The coating is like gravel. It dries out the tone too much. It's like playing thick sandpaper.
The G2's sing better IMO.
Really? The G plus is thinner than the G2 isn't it? Is the coating different than the G2?
To my ears the frosty "coating" takes a nice sounding head and gives it a slappy plasticky attack with no added warmth.
I didn't realize the G plus was frosted, thanks for the warning.
A G2 has a traditional sprayed-on coating such as that found on coated G1s and coated Ambassadors. The Evans EC1, EC2, and G-plus versions that they call "coated" have a frosty textured finish, not a coating.
Traditional coatings tame some of the high overtones, reduce sustain a smidge, and warm up the sound. To my ears the frosty "coating" takes a nice sounding head and gives it a slappy plasticky attack with no added warmth.
And yes, the G-plus is thinner: one 12mil ply vs. the G2's two 7mil plies.
May I suggest that what you are hearing is the application of coating on two drum heads that are very different. The difference between a EC2 and G2 are profound due to the EC ring, while the difference between a G+ Coated and G1 Coated is due to the different films used. Regardless you are not comparing apples to apples when comparing the coatings white vs. frosted.
Abazuto,
What specifically is wrong with the sound of the 10" and 12"? Can you describe it? Also, what sound are you looking to acheive?