Thread: John Bonham
View Single Post
  #190  
Old 12-20-2005, 08:15 AM
Thinshells
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: John Bonham

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bonham to the moon
you talk about bonham like you knew him personally. You can read all the articles and books you want, but you can never truely know if there correct. You've never spoken to him, or probably spoken to someone who HAS spoken to him. So stop trying to make us all look like idiots, who gives a crap about how he hit the drum, all we know for sure is that he did hit it, AND VERY WELL. I hate people who are more in tune to a musicians personal life than what is actually coming out of the speakers. Oh and just to negate your comment, look at your avatar : )
Sounds like a whole lot of your posts. Talking authoritatively about music and people that were around before you were born to people that were there.

"Loosing Syd was the best thing Pink Floyd could have done."

--Ok, would you care to describe the way people felt from the start, the attude of Americans vs UK fans via a vis the musical scene, and just what this represented in terms of paradigm shift for ther band's musical direction?

Blue man group ripping off stomp? Really? brilliant observation, as if it were chronologically possible. It seems that they both cleverly concealed this information of thier respective websites.

How many Zep concerts did you attend? You talk about Bonham like you knew him personally AND no one else knows him at all.

Reminds me of Matt Damons character in "Good Will Hunting"
The guy reads something, so he's a total expert on the subject. But can he describe the mood inside the Sistine chapel? The smell? The attitude of the people there?

Not without actually experiencing it. Just like not knowing Pink floyd during personnel transitions, and what the music meant to fans at the time before the changes.

At least learn to hate and attack others posts based on actual facts and experiance. So you worship Bonham, don't like blue man group. So you can form an opinion. It's not the same thing, especially if you weren't there and get the timeline completely wrong. Establishing an accurate criteria for an opinion should be the first thing you do. There are people here who have more historical perpective on Bonham than you do as well as an educated historian's point of view, perhaps you have read input from NuthaJason before? He just might have a better lock on things than you do.

Touche.

Last edited by Thinshells; 12-20-2005 at 11:53 AM.
Reply With Quote