Skin Man, you aren't really making any points. Neil Peart is as good as he is. You think he's "over-rated"? Great, you made your point about your opinion. Move along if you have nothing to add. The purpose of this forum is to talk about drummers, not to just repeat that you don't think one is the best drummer ever. You could go from thread to thread saying that each drummer is over-rated and isn't the best drummer ever. How does that add to any discussion?
And the other 164 posts on this thread have been made by people making points about their
opinions. I think the real lesson here is don't say anything that might annoy the Neil Peart fans because they are very dedicated.