Danny Carey vs Neil Peart

Pollyanna

Platinum Member
Hahaha ... someone will say it so I might as well ...

Very few of us at the forum believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities.

Having said that, we still flock to these threads like moths to a flame - usually to say how we don't don't believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities:)

For the record I love Danny Carey's playing but Neil doesn't do much for me, although there's no denying he's one of the elite drummers. Still, I find Tool's music much more inspiring than Rush's, and that's no doubt coloured my view.

So my final answer is Bill Bruford :p
 

JPW

Silver Member
If we are talking about basketball, I think Carey will win. =P

If we are talking about drumming we would first need some sort of set of rules.
 

Thaard

Platinum Member
Who is betar? Joye Jordsioon or Tarvsi Bakrer????????????

I tink Jyoee becuz hes fast in dubble base peddle!!!!!!!
 

alparrott

Platinum Member
In the category "Heaviest Drumset", Danny wins with his solid metal drumshells, although it was a close thing.

In the category "Spiffiest Hat Collection", Neil walks away with this one for his myriad African hats, not to mention his trucker hats he wears at rehearsals.

In the category "Shortest Band Name", it's a tie.

So there you have it. Dead even in all the areas that matter.

...

...now then:
 

Attachments

bilkay

Senior Member
Hahaha ... someone will say it so I might as well ...

Very few of us at the forum believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities.

Having said that, we still flock to these threads like moths to a flame - usually to say how we don't don't believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities:)

For the record I love Danny Carey's playing but Neil doesn't do much for me, although there's no denying he's one of the elite drummers. Still, I find Tool's music much more inspiring than Rush's, and that's no doubt coloured my view.

So my final answer is Bill Bruford :p
Ditto...................................
 

Nodiggie

Gold Member
Truck Drivers vs. Service Writers.....

The Writer always wins ....

Unless the driver brings 2 for 3 McMuffins and Monster in the morning.


Parts Manager vs. Mechanics... Parts Manager ALWAYS wins, no exceptions !!
 

shadowlorde

Senior Member
being that all the other replies on this thread make no sense .... what would you do if you woke up in the middle of the night tied shirtless to a bed ,covered in marshmallow fluff, and surrounded by midget clowns?
 

Pocket-full-of-gold

Platinum Member
being that all the other replies on this thread make no sense .... what would you do if you woke up in the middle of the night tied shirtless to a bed ,covered in marshmallow fluff, and surrounded by midget clowns?
Initially, I panicked......but then once I relaxed.......oh.....wait, sorry.......

This is definitely best left for my memoirs.
 
J

Jeff Gordon #24

Guest
Hahaha ... someone will say it so I might as well ...

Very few of us at the forum believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities.

Having said that, we still flock to these threads like moths to a flame - usually to say how we don't don't believe in those kinds of comparisons and the whole "vs" thing because each drummer has his/her own qualities:)

For the record I love Danny Carey's playing but Neil doesn't do much for me, although there's no denying he's one of the elite drummers. Still, I find Tool's music much more inspiring than Rush's, and that's no doubt coloured my view.

So my final answer is Bill Bruford :p

Ehh...


I'll take Vinny.

Thread over!
 
Top